
While planning my first empowered homebirth 9 years ago I would hear quite often that I was brave. And I would smile and move the conversation along to another subject reasoning that the person I was speaking with was too ignorant of the truth to actually engage on the subject of birth. But until my mind had settled into the new topic of conversation I would be waging a battle inside my head: I would be screaming how “brave” has nothing to do with it.
From what I’ve heard from other pregnant women since, I was not alone. Many thinking women today seem frustrated with the obstination they face in society. They even form whole groups which declare their lack of bravery as a means to spread their message.
But I’m rethinking that position. I wondered long and hard over the years why they thought it was so brave. Ignorance, obviously, but was that all? I hoped for a better excuse than that for the people I encountered.
While it is still unnerving to have someone look at you in wonder and amazement as if you have a third eye or are a circus act, and the truth of the matter is that taking responsibility for your own childbirth in an effort to work with the process is the safest approach, it is also brave.
It is, in fact, quite brave to have a baby at home.
It takes a lot of bravery to seek the truth.
Most people are content with mediocrity. If you don’t know this, just look at the reason you’re here: Women (and people in general) are so inclined to go with what appears the easiest, that we eventually end up with birth looking like a medical miracle instead of the natural order. To even so much as wonder anything aside from what we’ve been conditioned to believe takes a lot. To actively pursue the truth when ignorance is such bliss is quite brave.
It takes a lot of bravery to challenge the establishment.
You’re not trying to challenge anything, I know. You just want to find the safest and healthiest path for your baby. But in so doing, the establishment is challenged by you! The men involved have spent their entire careers focused on this topic. The institution has spent generations indoctrinating western medicine, including the medicalization of birth, into a large portion of the world. For any lay person to question a self-declared expert in their field of study, let alone a woman in such a “delicate” state, is not generally appreciated.
It takes a lot of bravery to follow your own path.
The masses are loud, and apathetic, and condemning. They don’t understand why you don’t just do what’s normal, and don’t really care to understand because then they’d have to deal with the issue in their own lives, too. It’s much easier to make harsh judgments, criticize you over them, and go back to their regularly scheduled programs. So not only are you on your own, alone, but you must also then defend these choices, advocate for yourself and your baby, and develop thick skin while hormones rage, you’re needing to nest and have support, and you feel most vulnerable.
But you, you push through. You persevere, you do what it takes, you challenge yourself and do what you know to be best for your birth and your baby, fully aware of all the risks, including that of losing relationship with friends and family.
Now I like to think that every time someone tells me I’m brave, that they’re not really commenting on me at all, but themselves. They know they’re not brave, they know they’re not strong enough to challenge their own thoughts, let alone a system, to find the truth, and go down that narrow path. And when they tell me that so boldly I can’t help but hold my head up high and say “Thank you”.
Your turn!
Does it bother you to be called brave? How have you dealt with it?
Share your thoughts in the comments!


ShareThis



Hi Jeannie,
This is a really provocative post. I live in Brazil, where natural birth means induction and epidural and people think that that is brave. Whenever I tell anyone here that I had a homebirth, they first ask if it was planned (I wasn’t just caught by surprise and in a taxi) and the next statement is “Que coragem” What courage. My response has been “Eu não tive coragem pra ir por hospital.” I didn’t have the courage to go the hospital. The hospitals here have an upward of 80% Cesarean rate.
There is truth in this statement- I was terrified to go to a hospital in a country where I speak the language but was not fluent at the time (had been here less than a year) where I knew the doctors had little to NO experience with natural birth.
However reading you article made me acknowledge that my response is a bit tongue-in-cheek- a way to invert the roles and make people think.
You are right- it is brave to challenge the status quo- to make it so important that you are willing to have uncomfortable conversations with many people you know who think you may be voluntarily putting yourself and your child at risk. It is brave to challenge the dominant paradigm.
And most of all, it is very brave as a woman to take control of your own body. I am so glad that I did.
I wish this courage for so many women, and I hope that they see that in our reflections.
Thanks, Kimberly! It’s nice to meet you.
I couldn’t imagine finding myself facing such odds. And I thought we had it bad here in the U.S.! Yikes. That would either terrify me or make choosing homebirth pretty easy!
If you’d like to share your story sometime, I’d be glad to post it!
Hi Jeannie!
I live in Iceland where we have an excellent healthcare system and relativly open minded community regarding childbirth. I know women who have chosen homebirth and faced the same surprised awe. I would probably have considered it for my second birth, but because of complications during my first pregnancy I didn’t have the option to.
I just wanted to share my own feelings about this, since I DO think women who decide on homebirth ARE brave. Brave to stand up to skeptics and to do what they want based on their own knowledge, instinct and feelings.
In other words, I agree with you
Found you via MwP and glad I did. Am going to read some more on here
My best,
ThoreyO
ThoreyO recently posted..5 Easy Steps to Writing Rhyme-Free Poetry
Thanks! It’s nice to meet you
I enjoyed your post on Rhyme-Free Poetry. I’m going to give it a try next time I’m ‘locked’.
Good to hear
I would love it if you comment on my post and tell me about how it worked for you once you’ve tried 
ThoreyO recently posted..5 Easy Steps to Writing Rhyme-Free Poetry